:. Food Industry News


Sugar Row Ferments between EU and Tropical Growers

Source: Reuters
10/12/2008

Geneva, Dec 10 - A trade row over sugar is building as tropical producers directly contradict claims by the European Union about the state of negotiations on the product.

Daily News Alerts

EU Agriculture Commissioner Mariann Fischer Boel told sugar growers in France, the European Union's biggest producer, on Tuesday that sugar issues had been settled to the EU's advantage in negotiations at the World Trade Organisation (WTO).

But Costa Rica's WTO ambassador, Ronald Saborio Soto, said an agreement on the status of sugar and other products had been abandoned after the EU walked away from a deal on bananas when a WTO meeting of ministers on the Doha global trade round collapsed in July. "The question is completely open," Saborio, who coordinates tropical products countries at the WTO, told Reuters.

WTO Director-General Pascal Lamy is considering whether to call ministers to Geneva later this month to have another attempt at a breakthrough on the Doha round, which could help cushion the impact of a global economic slowdown.

In preparation for the possible meeting, the chairmen of WTO talks on agriculture and industrial goods issued new negotiating texts on Saturday to serve as blueprints for ministers.

CONTRADICTIONS AND BANANAS

But the farm proposals contain a contradiction which cannot be resolved until a decades-old dispute over bananas is settled.

One proposal would see tariffs on tropical products from Latin American growers come down faster and more steeply than the general cuts on agricultural goods.

But another would allow rich countries to reduce tariffs more slowly on products from poor developing countries who currently enjoy preferential access to their markets.

This is to give the developing countries, represented by the African, Caribbean and Pacific (ACP) group of mainly former European colonies, more time to adjust to the loss of their relative advantage as markets open up with lower duties.

Clearly, many products could be on both lists, and a Doha deal will only be possible if there is agreement on the overlaps, otherwise either the Latin Americans or ACP countries could block a deal under the WTO's consensus-driven system.

"As I prepare to go to Geneva in a few days, what we have on the table in the Doha Round with regard to sugar is very encouraging," Fischer Boel said.

"Sugar will not be considered a 'tropical product'. Sugar will be on the list of products which will be affected by preference erosion," she told the French sugar beet growers' association CGB, according to a text of her remarks.

Sugar's presence on the preference erosion list means EU sugar tariffs will be cut over 8 years after a 2-year grace period, instead of being cut over 5 years, she noted.

But her comments seemed to be based on a compromise in July, when the Latin Americans grudgingly dropped sugar, rum, tobacco and other products from their list in return for an EU agreement to treat their bananas the same as fruit from ACP countries.

Bananas are crucial to the economy of many Latin American countries, such as Ecuador, the world's biggest grower.

"There is no agreement on any of the 42 products on which Tropical Products countries or ACP countries have differences," Saborio said.

"The fact that the EU decided not to comply with the standalone agreement on bananas brought the whole negotiation back to square one," he said.

EU officials have made it clear that if a Doha meeting goes ahead they are willing to revive July's agreement on bananas for the sake of an overall deal -- but with some adjustments.

One is that they cannot implement tariff cuts on bananas from Jan. 1 next year, which has infuriated the Latin American growers who say they will lose millions of dollars as a result.

Fischer Boel also revealed in her speech that the EU could let in a quota of 485,000-675,000 tonnes of sugar a year at low tariffs under WTO rules, if it decides to designate sugar as a sensitive product to shield it overall from full tariff cuts.



GO   View more articles on this subject


More Alerts from 10/12/2008


Email This Article To A Colleague     Print A Copy Of This Page
 
 
 
 
FLEXNEWS - Business News for the Food Industry

About Us | Contact Us | Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy
 
Daily News Alerts
Related Items
Most EU Exports Subsidies Except Sugar Fall in '06/07...
Austrian Sugar Beet Farmers and Sugar Industry Fear...
EU Radically Reforms Its Sugar Sector to Give Producers...
Bayer Barters Coffee and Sugar to Grease Wheels of...
Sugar Exporters Urge Rejection of Protectionism
Sugar Slips in Broad-Based Setback, Cocoa Off Lows
WTO to Broaden Focus in 2009 After Doha Setback
Coffee, Sugar Fall, US Auto Plan Failure Weighs
WTO Talks Need Signal from Obama, Brazil Says
Cocoa Buoyed by Slow W. Africa Bean Arrivals

More in Food Industry News
USA: Kehe Food Distributors Opens New Centre in Pennsylvania
Russia Duma Passes Beer Tax Hike in First Reading
Bongrain's Slowdown in Cheese Sales Continues as Group's...
Cadbury Descendant Fears Loss of Firm's UK Heritage
Sugar, Coffee Sideways, Eye Storm in Nicaragua
Ahold Set to Benefit Whether Predator or Prey
First UTZ CERTIFIED Cocoa to Be Delivered in Amsterdam,...
GLG Life Tech to Offer 3.6 Mln Shares for US IPO
Sainsbury H1 Profit Seen up 16 Percent, H2 Tougher
EU to Fight for Tuna Protection at Global Talks

Top Headlines
USA: Kehe Food Distributors Opens New Centre in Pennsylvania
Russia Duma Passes Beer Tax Hike in First Reading
Bongrain's Slowdown in Cheese Sales Continues as Group's...
Ahold Set to Benefit Whether Predator or Prey
GLG Life Tech to Offer 3.6 Mln Shares for US IPO
Sainsbury H1 Profit Seen up 16 Percent, H2 Tougher
UK: Continual Growth at Graham's The Family Dairy During...
Ajinomoto H1 FY09 Net Income Increases
Hain Celestial Reports Lower-than-Expected Quarterly...
AarhusKarlshamn's Food Ingredients Quarterly Operating...
SunOpta Q3 Revenue Drops 11.8%
Jones Soda Sees Revenue Decrease of 18% in Q3
UK: Tate and Lyle's Pre-tax Profits £112 Million...
Cha Dao Tea of Seattle Partners with BYB Brands
Coca-Cola Bottling Co. Consolidated Sees Income Growth...
California Pizza Kitchen Profit Up, Forecast Light
Starbucks Raises Outlook as Turnaround Signs Mount
Senomyx Quarterly Revenue Increases 3%
China: Yayi International to Build China's Largest...
Discovery of Pesticide Amitraz in Turkish Pears: EU...
Dr Pepper Snapple Profit Tops View
Sara Lee Reports Strong Fiscal 2010 First Quarter;...
Ahold Gears Up for M&A with Management Rejig
ICA AB Interim Report 2009: Net Income up 7.5 Percent
Process for Preparing a Highly-Soluble Cocoa Extract
Methods and Compositions for Improving the Nutritional...


 


FLEXNEWS 2009 - All rights reserved
ISSN 1950-6228