:. Food Industry News


UK: Food Miles May Be Green, but Are They Fair?

Source: Reuters
07/02/2007

London, Feb 7 - Supermarkets are scrambling to capture the millions of "green" pounds spent by increasingly environmentally aware shoppers.

Daily News Alerts

Farmers' markets across the country are buzzing with conscientious customers buying locally grown knobbly carrots and leeks pulled straight from the soil.

With the threat of climate change racing up the global political agenda, Britons are going green when they shop. And their sights are set on food miles.

"The concept of food miles has absolutely rightly entered into people's consciousness in Britain," says Bill Vorley, head of the sustainable markets group at the British International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED) think-tank.

The idea of reducing food miles seems straightforward -- simply buy produce which has travelled the shortest possible distance from farm to plate.

However, just as British consumers' enthusiasm to cut food miles is growing, some experts are warning that an over-simplistic view of the issue risks doing more harm than good.

They are urging policymakers not to rush blindly into formulating "buy-local-only" campaigns for consumers which could prove disastrous for many poor African food producers.

"I'm an advocate of local food, and I do think we need to re-localise our food procurement rather than hauling it up and down the motorways," says Vorley.

"But we are warning against allowing environmental arguments to trump the case for development -- especially when it guides decisions by policymakers or consumers that are going to have very little impact on our overall carbon footprint."

STRAWBERRIES AND SCHOOL RUNS

According to Britain's National Consumer Council (NCC) about 10 percent of the carbon dioxide emissions associated with British food transport come from air-freighted goods.

In a recent paper, the NCC said the carbon damage from air-freighting just one small punnet of New Zealand strawberries to Britain was equivalent to the CO2 emissions from 11 average school runs, made by parents driving their children to school.

The problem, experts say, is that consumers keen to do their bit for the environment but as yet unaware of the complexities of the debate are shopping with a simplistic "local good, foreign bad" attitude.

As long as the apples, carrots, broccoli and leeks are produced in Britain, they can be bought in abundance with a clear conscience, the thinking goes. But if the label says they come from Israel, Kenya or New Zealand, only a carbon criminal would dare take them to the checkout.

However, some argue that fair miles, not food miles, should be the criterion by which consumers judge the contents of their shopping trolleys. Specifically, fresh fruit and vegetables from sub-Saharan Africa, on which Britons spend more than a million pounds a day, should be considered more carefully.

"Many products which come to us from Africa are giving some of the poorest people in some of the poorest countries in the world a chance to earn a decent living," said Harriet Lamb, executive director of the Fairtrade Foundation, an independent certification body that guarantees poor producers in the developing world a fair price for their goods.

"People have to be careful in assessing the carbon footprint of a product, because it may well be that some products (from Africa) may actually have a smaller carbon footprint and a greater social impact than the same product grown in commercial greenhouses in Britain or the Netherlands."

A MILLION LIVELIHOODS

Lamb and Vorley warn consumers against feeling a false sense of environmental virtue if they avoid air-freighted products.

Cutting out products from sub-Saharan Africa would reduce Britain's overall contribution to global carbon dioxide emissions by just 0.1 percent, they say.

"And it's something like a million livelihoods that depend on us (in Britain) enjoying fresh fruit and vegetables from sub-Saharan Africa," says Lamb. "Let's make sure we're not making poor people in poor countries pay the price."

According to Stephen Mbugua, vice-chairman of the Fresh Produce Exporters Association of Kenya, that is not happening yet, but it is a great fear for the future.

"So far so good, we've not had any serious impact from this, (but) if there was a serious campaign, it certainly would affect our sales," he told Reuters in Nairobi.

Lamb quotes John Kanjangaile, export manager of a group in Tanzania called the Kagera Cooperative Union (KCU), speaking at a public meeting in Britain where he was asked about the potential environmental damage caused by his export business.

His reply was unequivocal: "With the deepest respect, the farmers in the villages where I come from don't have televisions, they don't have refrigerators, they don't have even one car, let alone two, they don't have motorbikes, they've never even been to our country's capital let alone flown all over the world on holiday -- so don't ask those farmers to pick up the cost of environmental problems you in the industrialised West have caused."



GO   View more articles on this subject

Email This Article To A Colleague     Print A Copy Of This Page
 
 
 
 
FLEXNEWS - Business News for the Food Industry

About Us | Contact Us | Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy
 
Daily News Alerts
Related Items
UK: 27-Month Custodial Sentence for Organic Food Fraud
UK Shoppers Want Ethical Food Without Paying More
Consumers Eye Values as Well as Value in Recession
UK Organic Food Sales Growth Slows
Britons Back Ethical Foods Despite Downturn; Organic...
Fall in UK Organic Food Sales Hits Marks & Spencer...
UK: Food and Drink Manufacturers Prevent Half a Million...
UK Organics Outlook Rosy Despite Food Inflation
UK Food Standards Agency to Review Fish Advice
UK Organic Group Says Air-Freight Food Ok if Aids Poor

More in Food Industry News
Procter & Gamble Repurchasing Shares, Quiet on...
US Shoppers Going Green Despite Struggling Economy
Wessanen Sells Liberty Richter to World Finer Foods
Cheesecake Factory Sticks to 2010 Forecast
Brenntag Changes 2.5 Bln Euro Loan to Allow IPO
European Commission Refers Greece to ECJ over Unjustified...
JM Smucker's Quarterly Net Income Increases 172%
Ferrero, Hershey Would Likely Break up Cadbury
Indonesia's Astra Agro Revises Up CPO Forecast
Cocoa Supplier Olam to Benefit from Consolidation Among...

Top Headlines
Procter & Gamble Repurchasing Shares, Quiet on...
US Shoppers Going Green Despite Struggling Economy
Wessanen Sells Liberty Richter to World Finer Foods
Cheesecake Factory Sticks to 2010 Forecast
European Commission Refers Greece to ECJ over Unjustified...
JM Smucker's Quarterly Net Income Increases 172%
Cocoa Supplier Olam to Benefit from Consolidation Among...
Avebe and National Starch Food Innovation to Expand...
Auchan Backs Hypermarkets as Rivals Rethink
Ferrero Could Eye Cadbury Gum, Candy Unit
Dole Food Posts Wider Q3 Loss
Fonterra Sells Stake in UK Joint Venture to Arla
Imperial Sugar Company Closes Three-Way Joint Venture...
PepsiCo to Invest $100 Million in Egypt in 2010
Ex-Parmalat Auditors Settle US Investor Lawsuit
Tesco in Broadband Push as Reaches Beyond Groceries
India Sugar Protest Forces Parliament to Shut
Kerry Group Keeps Full Year Earnings Growth Forecast
Nestle Professional to Acquire Vitality Foodservice
Pinnacle Foods Acquires Birds Eye Foods for USD 1.3...
DSM Makes Great Strides in Production Processes for...
Russian Grocer X5 Plans Higher 2010 Capex
Brazil: Laep in Talks to Sell Dairy Plant to Nestle
SunOpta Announces Opening of Natural and Organic Sesame...
Products Comprising, and Uses of, Decarboxylated Phenolic...
Process for the Preparation of Packaged Heat-Preserved...


 


FLEXNEWS 2009 - All rights reserved
ISSN 1950-6228